Hyundai IONIQ Forum banner

i-pedal as default when turning the car on

2 reading
44K views 139 replies 42 participants last post by  filiberti  
#1 ·
Hello

I do like drive with i-pedal but I don't find a setting where I can set i-pedal a dafault. Every time I turn the car on or have set it in park it goes back to level 3.
Is there a way to change the dafault setting to i-pedal?
 
#3 ·
That's right. Somewhat frustratingly you need to switch iPedal on every time you start the car. iPedal wil also disengage when you select reverse and needs to be manually selected again when you select drive.

iPedal also won't engage when you have your foot on the brake, unless the car is stopped. That's more inconvenient than you think, because often the first time you notice iPedal isn't on is when you have to brake to slow the car.

I like my new Ioniq 5, but it's little things like this that make the car frustrating to use.
 
#9 ·
I can't wait for someone to sue Hyundai over the fact that the car turns off i-Pedal driving when it is switched out of drive!!!! It should NOT do that without a BIG WARNING!!!

Someone is going to hit something soon and I'll testify for them that the car shouldn't have switched it off without a warning. This (and lack of rear wiper) are my only complaints about this car.

Come on Hyundai....FIX THIS NOW!!!!

Give us a default i-Pedal setting, and STOP changing the setting while we are driving!!!
 
#13 ·
It's a matter of expected function. If I am driving the car, and set it to i-Pedal, I expect the car to come to a stop when I release my foot from the pedal. When I drop off someone and have to reverse out of a parking spot (never stopped driving) the car changes the setting on me WITH NO WARNING!!! This is BAD and not the expected behavior.

Just like any function that the car changes, this one should include a warning at the very least, and the ability to say "don't do that".

When I'm driving and it disengages cruise or lane keeping etc, it gives me a warning.

I am not aware of any US regulation that mandates you can't keep i-Pedal settings while driving (and shifting from reverse to drive). That just doesn't exist.

So some of you like this behavior? Or just put up with it because....?
 
#14 ·
It's a matter of expected function. If I am driving the car, and set it to i-Pedal, I expect the car to come to a stop when I release my foot from the pedal. When I drop off someone and have to reverse out of a parking spot (never stopped driving) the car changes the setting on me WITH NO WARNING!!! This is BAD and not the expected behavior.

Just like any function that the car changes, this one should include a warning at the very least, and the ability to say "don't do that".

When I'm driving and it disengages cruise or lane keeping etc, it gives me a warning.

I am not aware of any US regulation that mandates you can't keep i-Pedal settings while driving (and shifting from reverse to drive). That just doesn't exist.

So some of you like this behavior? Or just put up with it because....?
I understand you.

But there are way more sue reasons in USA, must of them will never work in Europe, so what I am saying is, if this come to a court I can't see any reason it ever will work in Europe because it's not even a court worth.
 
#15 ·
I absolutely agree that this is a safety concern. Sometimes the i-Pedal disconnects unexepectedly and I don't notice that until I go to slow down - and note the car isn't responding as usual. The i-Pedal is brilliant, and provides so much smoother a driving experience than on rival models (looking at you, jerky Tesla). Not only should it hold that setting once it is selected, it really ought to be the default.
 
#23 ·
It's fine to say I would prefer this function to perform/operator this or that way. It's another to say it's dangerous because you or some don't like how it was designed. So many of us are using i-padel and driving everyday safely. It's one thing to make suggestions for improvement or state on how some functions work. Don't over state the seriousness of a function when it's not.
 
#26 ·
Sorry, but it IS dangerous to change the way a car drives without notifying the driver!!!! This is simple user interface design!!!! When driving a car (a deadly weapon) you don't turn off AUTO BREAKING without notifying the driver!!!!

So sorry you don't agree that this simple UI concept is sound and tested, but that doesn't make it right. NEVER EVER change a drive setting on me WHILE I'M STILL DRIVING THE CAR, WITHOUT WARNING ME!!!!! EVER!!!!
 
#27 · (Edited)
I don't agree. Here are some examples when you don't need to manually turn features off 1) So because you did not turn off charging, the battery should over charge and explode 2) auto headlight - because you didn't turn the headlight off, it should stay on and drain your 12v battery 3) because you didn't turn off your radio, it should stay on after turning your car off and drain your 12v battery. I can give you more examples by your definition that features should stay on until you intend to turn them off.

I do agree that the manufacturer could better operationally design some functions. Many of these functions are perferences. Some people like i-pedal to stay on all the time, some people don't or don't care. Some people like yellow headlights, some people like white. Guess when you own your own car company, you can design a car that has every feature for everyone. God forbid if any anyone doesn't like a feature because they feel it's dangerous.

Again, I've learned to drive the car safely with all of it's unperfect features. Been very happy with the car since day 1.
 
#29 ·
Those are some of the dumbest examples.....in fact, thanks or posting examples of User Interfaces that work well to support a driver. Each of these does something FOR a driver so he/she doesn't have to do something for themselves. The example we are talking about - Turning OFF I-Pedal when you reverse the car to turn around while dropping off someone....what exactly is this doing to HELP the driver? NOTHING. In fact, it is forcing the driver to turn something back ON that the car just decided on its own, for NO REASON, to turn off! Try again.

@Flybuddy I've never said that I personally would sue Hyundai over this, but speculate that if they don't fix it soon, someone will. And in particular, I'm talking about the part where the car turns off I-Pedal when you go into reverse. No change of driver, no parking, no stop.....I pull into a driveway to drop someone off, reverse out, and presto, it turned it off, changing how the car brakes without notifying me. There is no defense for this.

If I used @michaelf3 dumb examples, it would be like me turning on my headlights to auto, and when I back out of the driveway the car turns them off. Or I turn on my auto dimming headlights, and when I back out of the driveway, it turns auto dimming off.
 
#28 ·
I've gotten to the point where I'm surprised if I let my foot off the gas and I-pedal is working. Seriously though, if anyone has strong convictions about it being very unsafe, then don't use it. When public statements are made in writing it makes for a difficult legal aspect. When a defending attorney points to these statements and asks "if you felt this was so unsafe why did you continually use it?" How would you answer? It may not get the manufacturer off the hook for something unsafe but it would surely diminish the case and payout. While I don't like the current setup and would strongly prefer an I-pedal default, I don't believe it rises to the level of serious consequences.
 
#32 ·
I agree it's annoying that the car will not start/stay in iPedal as a default if that's the way you've been driving before reversing, parking, etc. I certainly wish that it did so and would encourage others to continue making noise to Hyundai about this minor but annoying shortcoming. That said, it does only revert to L3 (at least in my experience) which is the next best thing to iPedal and not dramatically different (as opposed to full-coast L0), so I think it's a stretch to say that it's a significant safety issue. If you consider it unacceptably dangerous then I'd suggest just staying in L3 all the time.

It may be that there is some drivetrain-related design issue that does not allow the car to go straight to iPedal from power-up, reverse, etc. I have noticed that sometimes in L3, shortly after driving away from the house, it will not allow me to switch to iPedal under certain conditions, almost always when I'm in the process of slowing for a stop sign or red light. The car displays a message about iPedal drive conditions not being met or some such. Rather than just being a stupid UI oversight to reset to L3 after reversing, etc., maybe that is happening because the car believes for whatever reason that iPedal conditions are not met then either. This still seems like a flaw of course, but it may be more complicated to fix from an engineering standpoint than many of us would wish.
 
#39 ·
Driving is dangerous. We don't need to make it any MORE dangerous because of stupid software designs.
maybe there's some regulations governing this?

As the operator of the worlds largest jet boat forum, I can tell you that Hyundai monitors this forum and others for feedback, just like Yamaha monitors the forum I operate (they told me this in person when I attend their media previews and new boat media events). So I know they are reading this and taking notes. Hopefully its just a matter of time before they push a fix (hopefully before somone in the US sues them....or they just settle to fix the damage).
or maybe they see you're the only one calling the way it works as 'dangerous' and they don't worry about it.

Sorry, but it IS dangerous to change the way a car drives without notifying the driver!!!! This is simple user interface design!!!! When driving a car (a deadly weapon) you don't turn off AUTO BREAKING without notifying the driver!!!!

So sorry you don't agree that this simple UI concept is sound and tested, but that doesn't make it right. NEVER EVER change a drive setting on me WHILE I'M STILL DRIVING THE CAR, WITHOUT WARNING ME!!!!! EVER!!!!
do you use cruise control? climate control? do you turn off all the safety features like collision braking because it will brake in an emergency warning you at about the same time with beeps and lights?
 
#38 ·
It's way too funny, as someone who drove stick-shift manual transmission trucks/cars for many years, to read someone else complain about a car not doing every-little-feature automatically. LOL

I tend to prefer Level 1 when I have a passenger, and I-Pedal when driving solo. So I'm already in the mindset of setting the regen away from the default Level 3. As far as the "unsafe" aspect of it being in Level 3 when I want it in I-Pedal, IMHO the difference in the deceleration between the two settings when letting my foot off the accelerator isn't enough to be unsafe. It's not like we're talking about the difference between I-Pedal and Level 1.
 
#60 · (Edited)
The difference is continuing to roll when you think the car will be stopping. That's unsafe. Maybe because you don't use it you don't understand. I have hit the breaks hard just realizing it has pulled me out of ipedal. You may not realize for a while as you may not need to stop for a bit. It's very scary. Oh and i also drove stick for years. Get with the times things are automatic these days and of course we want it.
 
#48 ·
I agree it's annoying that the car will not start/stay in iPedal as a default if that's the way you've been driving before reversing, parking, etc. I certainly wish that it did so and would encourage others to continue making noise to Hyundai about this minor but annoying shortcoming. That said, it does only revert to L3 (at least in my experience) which is the next best thing to iPedal and not dramatically different (as opposed to full-coast L0), so I think it's a stretch to say that it's a significant safety issue. If you consider it unacceptably dangerous then I'd suggest just staying in L3 all the time.

It may be that there is some drivetrain-related design issue that does not allow the car to go straight to iPedal from power-up, reverse, etc. I have noticed that sometimes in L3, shortly after driving away from the house, it will not allow me to switch to iPedal under certain conditions, almost always when I'm in the process of slowing for a stop sign or red light. The car displays a message about iPedal drive conditions not being met or some such. Rather than just being a stupid UI oversight to reset to L3 after reversing, etc., maybe that is happening because the car believes for whatever reason that iPedal conditions are not met then either. This still seems like a flaw of course, but it may be more complicated to fix from an engineering standpoint than many of us would wish.
The worst bit about turning off i-Pedal at every excuse, is that it is also linked to creep. When you select drive, the car will start moving all by itself. Not
maybe there's some regulations governing this?



or maybe they see you're the only one calling the way it works as 'dangerous' and they don't worry about it.



do you use cruise control? climate control? do you turn off all the safety features like collision braking because it will brake in an emergency warning you at about the same time with beeps and lights?
He isn't the only one calling it dangerous. Making the car less predictable is dangerous. Making it drive off by itself when you go from reverse to drive is dangerous. Yes, you can work round the problem, but there is always that fraction of a second where you wonder why it's moving and then have to press the brake. One day someone will hit a cyclist or take evasive action and crash because of it.